Log in
Account
Account
Tools

Ash

Holds stocks that have risen steadily over the past year. Traders call this momentum; we tested it on NSE stocks after costs.

Verdict

Tested, not picked

Not adopted. A research result, not advice.

Checks measured
8
Random portfolios beaten
12 of 20
Max drawdown
−29.7%

Robustness checks

What each check asks →
  1. Six start datesMeasured+27.3% a year on average, worst start +20.9%
  2. Worse prices (0.3% each way)Measured+19.6%
  3. Without its 5 best winnersMeasured+8.3%
  4. From 2023 onwardsMeasured+38.7%
  5. 2023 onwards, without 5 best winnersMeasured+11.9%
  6. Random-pick portfoliosMeasuredBeats 12 of 20 random-stock portfolios built like Birch
  7. Biggest winner's share of profitMeasured24%
  8. Worst fallMeasured−28% average, −30% at the worst start

Measured: each figure is reported without a pass mark, because no pass line was set for this model.

PerformanceBacktest, hypothetical, costs included

CAGR
+20.9%
NIFTY 500 CAGR
+12.3%
Max drawdown
−29.7%
Sharpe
1.08
Trades
266
CAGR 2023 on
+38.7%
₹100 became, weekly
2026-10-28Ash 756Random ×20 730(309–1,134)NIFTY 500 349Beats 12/20

Charts © 2023 TradingView, Inc.

Fall from the last peak
2026-10-28Drawdown −4.3%Worst −29.5%, 2018-08-27 to 2020-03-23, recovered 2020-12-03

Charts © 2023 TradingView, Inc.

Backtest, hypothetical, costs included. Weekly points from daily NSE prices. 20 random-pick portfolios use the same stake size and costs.
Year by year
YearModelNIFTY 500Change
2026+67.5%−8.9%+76.4%
2025−1.2%+6.6%−7.8%
2024+27.9%+15.3%+12.6%
2023+63.6%+25.6%+38.1%
2022−5.9%+3.9%−9.9%
2021+62.9%+31.2%+31.6%
2020+25.5%+15.4%+10.1%
2019−3.5%+8.6%−12.1%
2018−5.5%−4.2%−1.3%
2017+47.7%+40.4%+7.3%
2016−15.7%+8.0%−23.7%

The first and last years are part years.

Holding now

Loading…

Where next