Log in
Account
Account
Tools

Study · · By Shashank

Do stocks resting near a 52-week high keep rising?

Verdict

Tested, not pickedBacktest, hypothetical, costs included

From January 2016 it grew 30.2% a year, with a worst fall of 34.6%. Without its 5 best stocks it grew 17.7% a year, and the six start dates averaged 29.2%.

On this page

The short answer

Does holding strong stocks while they rest near their yearly high grow money steadily? It grew well over ten years, but not steadily. A few big winners carried it, and its falls were deep. We did not adopt it.

Strong stocks often pause just below their yearly high, moving in a narrow range before the next leg up. We tested holding such stocks while they rest, and closing the position when the trend breaks. This study tested the model we call Aspen.

How did we test it?

  • The idea: hold strong stocks that rest in a narrow range near their yearly high, and close the position when the trend breaks. New positions are taken only while the wider market is in an uptrend.
  • The stocks: the most-traded NSE stocks, refreshed each month.
  • The shared test setup: ₹10 lakh, 1.5% of capital at risk per position, at most 12% in one stock and 30 positions, Zerodha delivery charges and 0.1% slippage per side.
  • The period: one run from 19 January 2016 to 28 October 2026. Six start dates, one a year from 2016 to 2021, were also run to the same end.

What did we find?

Not adopted. Aspen came back to the site on 5 November 2026. The first study had rejected it because it held up poorly on years it had not seen.

CheckResult
Growth per year30.2%
Worst fall34.6%
Without the 5 best stocks17.7%
Average of the six start dates29.2%
2023 onwards33.5%
Trades299
Year20162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
Return8%115%−3%11%30%113%−18%82%25%−5%38%
  • Most of the growth came in three years: 2017, 2021 and 2023.
  • Without its 5 best stocks it grows 17.7% a year, against 30.2% with them. A few big winners carried it.
  • Its worst fall, 34.6%, was deeper than Birch's over the same run.

What are the limits?

  • The price data holds only companies still listed today. That flatters every result here.
  • The model's settings were chosen on 2016 to 2022, and later years have been looked at since.